Patent Pending
  An ePublishing marketplace for journalism, ideas and expertise.
News Hubs
The Beats

Video: Oral arguments before Florida appeal court in Watchdog City journalists public records suit

City Desk Naples-Marco Island, Florida
Paid Story 1
Paid Videos 1
Login to follow this story
Login to forward story to a friend

Share This Story On:

Journalist's Info
Gina Edwards
Account Type: Journalist
View Profile & Work History
Credibility: 100% Positive ( 13 )
Has credibility
Is Balanced and Objective
Shows Respect
Acts with independence
Is a watchdog
Member since: 10/16/2009
View Journalist's Other Stories
View Journalist's News Hubs
Wire: Get Email Alerts
Embed Wire alert
Report Abuse

VIDEO: Florida Appeal Court hears oral arguments in Watchdog City journalists’ public records lawsuit challenging fees by Collier Clerk Brock

Brock conceded journalist's initial suit correct in new public records policy posted online, but has spent $67,000 in tax dollars on legal bills to fight over $556 bill

Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal heard oral arguments on May 6, 2015 in the appellate case brought by Collier Clerk of Courts Dwight Brock against Watchdog City journalist Gina Edwards.

Presiding were Judges Stevan T. Northcutt, Darryl C. Casanueva, and Anthony K. Black.

Edwards is represented by Marrett Hanna, Ryan Witmer and Giovani Mesa, who is with the O’Boyle law firm. Hanna and Witmer were previously with the firm. Brock is represented by Steve Blount.

Brock appealed after Edwards won favorable rulings two times in the trial court in 2014 in her public records lawsuit protesting the high fees charged to her by Brock’s office for county government records. After earlier charging her only $1 for hundreds of pages of scanned documents on CD, Brock charged Edwards $556, or $1 per page for scanned electronic documents on 2 CDs after she published investigative stories critical of Brock and his audit of his former political challenger.

Edwards filed suit based on two Attorney General opinions and Florida’s Government in the Sunshine Manual which says Clerks are required to charge lower fees under Florida’s public records law for county government records. Brock contends that he is governed only by the Clerk’s statute and can charge $1 per page for any document in his possession, including for electronic records.

A favorable ruling for Edwards at the appellate level will benefit all Floridians by holding Clerks around the state to the lower fee schedule under the public records law, F.S. 119.

A win by Brock could raise public records fees on members of the public and journalists around the state — by six fold and more — by allowing Clerks to charge significantly higher rates for county government records, whether in paper or electronic format.

See additional info below:

Conact Gina Edwards at 239-514-1336 or at

Read the appellate filings

Edwards’ March 16, 2015 response

Brock’s Feb. 9, 2015 response

Edwards’ initial appeal brief filed on Jan. 20, 2015

Brock’s initial appeal brief filed on Oct. 30, 2014 

See more key court filings from both sides here. 

Read related stories, press releases and court filings from both sides and coverage by other media.

Related Coverage 

Editorial February 27, 2015 in Naples Daily News 

Previous Editorial by News-Press





Other Images 
No images in the gallery
Paid Story
You don't have permission to view. Please pay for this story to gain access.
Paid Video
Ask a question or post a comment about this story
No comments have been posted yet.
Please login in order to ask the seller a question.